Get in touch
Have a project in mind? Tell us a bit about it.
For most plumbers, electricians, clinics and other local service businesses, a Search campaign is the better long-term choice, because you pick the searches you pay for, see every search term, and send each service to its own page. A Smart campaign is fine when your budget is small, you sell one main service in one area, and nobody has time to look at the account every week. So the smart campaign vs Search campaign decision comes down to whether you have outgrown the simple setup Google gave you at sign-up.
Most owners never chose a Smart campaign. Google offers it during sign-up, the ads start running, and months later someone asks on r/adwords whether to keep it (“Transitioning from Smart Campaigns to Search”) or whether Google’s AI is “smarter than me” and should just be left alone. The answers below are what we tell owners in that spot.
Smart campaign vs Search campaign: what is the actual difference?
A Smart campaign hands the keywords, bids, ad assets and placements to Google, and a Search campaign hands them to you. Google’s own comparison of Smart and Search campaigns lays it out, and this table adds the parts that matter most to a business that lives on phone calls.
| What you are deciding | Smart campaign | Search campaign |
|---|---|---|
| Which searches you pay for | You enter keyword themes (Google suggests about 7 to 10) and Google AI generates the keywords | You choose every keyword and its match type: broad, “phrase” or [exact] |
| Bids | Google manages bidding inside your budget | You choose the bid strategy, such as Maximize clicks or Target CPA |
| Where ads appear | Google Search, Maps, YouTube and partner websites, including the Display Network | Google Search, with search partners and the Display Network as settings you switch on or off |
| Landing pages | One per campaign | Several per campaign, so each service can have its own page |
| Reports | A simplified dashboard plus a search terms report | Reports at campaign, ad group, ad, keyword and search term level |
| Blocking bad searches | Negative keyword themes | Negative keywords in broad, phrase or exact match |
| Phone calls | Reported calls through a Google forwarding number, with duration and area code | Call conversions that count only calls longer than a minimum length you set |
| Campaign goal | One goal per campaign, fixed once setup is done | Set by the conversion actions you track |
Sources for each row: keyword themes, keyword match types, how Smart campaigns work, negative keyword themes, negative keywords, reported calls, phone call conversion tracking and goals in Smart campaigns.
Are Google Smart campaigns any good for a local business?
They can be, if you have one main service, one service area and a budget too small to pay anyone to manage it. Google describes them as needing minimal ongoing management, and for a solo tradesperson that is worth something.
They fall short on control. A single keyword theme stands for many similar words and phrases, so your ad can show for searches you would never have picked, and the only way to find out is to read the search terms report. Your money can also go to YouTube and partner websites as well as Search and Maps. To see the split, open the campaign and select the spend amount above the Impressions figures, as described in Google’s page on clicks and costs in Smart campaigns. If a large share is going outside Search and Maps and those clicks are not turning into calls, that is your first sign the campaign needs tighter control.
If you are still deciding whether paid search suits your business at all, start with is Google Ads worth it for a small business.
How do I know if I am running a Smart campaign?
If your campaign page has a card called “Keyword themes & search terms report” where a keyword list would normally be, you are running a Smart campaign. Google only lets you create Smart campaigns in Smart Mode, and accounts outside Smart Mode get the other campaign types, including Search (About Smart campaigns benefits and features).
When should I switch from a Smart campaign to a Search campaign?
Switch when the search terms report shows you paying for searches you would never have chosen, or when you need a feature Smart campaigns don’t have. Run through this checklist. Two or more yeses usually means it is time.
- The search terms report shows job seekers, DIY questions, suppliers or towns you don’t cover, and adding negative keyword themes isn’t keeping up.
- You sell several services (say, emergency repairs and planned installs) that deserve different pages, and a Smart campaign allows one landing page per campaign.
- You want to count only calls long enough to be real enquiries. Search campaigns can count a call as a conversion only when it passes a minimum length you set.
- Spend is going to YouTube or partner sites and you want those placements off without filling in a request form.
- You want different bids for different jobs, because a boiler install is worth far more to you than a tap washer.
- You or someone you pay can spend time each week on search terms, bids and ads. Without that time, a Search campaign drifts too.
If none of these apply and the calls are coming in at a cost you are happy with, there is no prize for switching early.
How do I move from a Smart campaign to a Search campaign without starting from zero?
Build a new Search campaign from what the Smart campaign has already shown you, then pause the Smart campaign once the new one is live. Google says you cannot change a campaign to a new campaign type once it’s been created, so there is no convert button.
- Copy the search terms. Open the Smart campaign, go to the “Keyword themes & search terms report” card, click Edit, then the Search terms report tab (Google’s steps). List the terms that brought clicks you wanted, and separately the ones you never want to pay for.
- Copy the locations. Note the radius, postcodes or cities on the Location card, and check the location report to see where your clicks actually came from (location settings in Smart campaigns).
- Get the account out of Smart Mode. Search campaigns are created outside Smart Mode. Google’s old “About Smart Mode and Expert Mode” help page now redirects to the Smart campaigns overview and the switch has moved around between interface updates, so if you can’t find the option to switch to Expert Mode in your account, ask Google Ads support to point you to it.
- Turn good search terms into keywords. Group them by service, one ad group per service, and use phrase or exact match for the terms that brought real enquiries.
- Turn bad search terms into negative keywords. Negative keywords don’t match close variants, so add the singular and plural or the other spellings you saw in the report. Our negative keywords list for trades is a good place to start.
- Point each ad group at its own page, so someone searching for an EV charger lands on the EV charger page.
- Set up call conversion tracking with a minimum call length that filters out wrong numbers and quick hang ups. It needs Google forwarding numbers, which are available in many countries but not all (phone call conversion tracking).
- Check the network settings. In the new campaign, go to Settings, expand Networks, and decide whether search partners and the Display Network stay on.
- Pause the Smart campaign when the Search campaign starts serving. Running both on the same searches makes it hard to tell which one produced the calls. Google lets you pause indefinitely or schedule a pause, so you can bring it back if the Search campaign struggles (pause or resume a Smart campaign).
What does that look like for a real trade business?
Here is a worked example with example figures, not client data. An electrician runs a Smart campaign with the keyword themes “electrician”, “electrical repair” and “ev charger installation”, a 15 km radius and the call goal. After a couple of months the search terms report shows something like this.
| Search term in the report | What it tells you | What it becomes in the Search campaign |
|---|---|---|
| emergency electrician near me | Urgent job, high value | Phrase and exact keyword in an “Emergency” ad group, sent to the emergency page |
| ev charger installer | Planned job with a bigger ticket | Its own “EV chargers” ad group and landing page |
| electrician apprenticeship | Job seeker | Negative keywords: apprenticeship and apprentice (both, since negatives skip close variants) |
| electrician salary | Job seeker | Negative keyword: salary |
| how to reset a tripped breaker | DIY question | Negative phrase “how to” |
| electrician in a town 40 km away | Outside the service area | Excluded location |
In the Smart campaign, the only levers for the bottom four rows are negative keyword themes and location exclusions, and the top two rows have to share one landing page.
Is a Smart campaign the same as Performance Max?
No. Performance Max is a goal-based campaign that gives advertisers with conversion goals access to all Google Ads inventory from one campaign, with Google AI moving budget and bids across channels and your creative assets doing most of the steering (choose the right campaign type). Smart campaigns are Google’s simplified option for small businesses in Smart Mode, steered by keyword themes. If you are choosing between Search and Performance Max for leads, we compare them in Search campaigns or Performance Max for lead generation.
Common mistakes when moving off a Smart campaign
- Deleting the Smart campaign first. Its search terms report is the best keyword research you have. Copy it, then pause.
- Adding dozens of keyword themes. Google suggests about 7 to 10 and warns that too many can show your ad for less relevant searches. Trim themes before you blame the campaign type.
- Using broad match on everything in the new campaign. Broad is the default match type, so a rushed Search campaign can end up as loose as the Smart one. Start the proven terms on phrase or exact.
- Counting every call as a lead. Set a minimum call length for call conversions, or the bidding will learn from wrong numbers.
- Expecting to change the goal later. A Smart campaign’s goal is fixed once setup is complete; a different goal means a new Smart campaign.
If you would rather hand this over, our Google Ads management for local service businesses covers the move from Smart to Search, with the first two months of management free while you keep funding your own ad budget.
FAQ
Can I run a Smart campaign without a website?
Yes. Google lets a Smart campaign send people to your website or to your Google Business Profile. Without a website you lose a page that answers questions and takes form enquiries, which we cover in do you need a website if you have a Google Business Profile.
Can I stop my Smart campaign showing on YouTube and other websites?
Partly. Google has an opt-out form for the Display Network, and requests are usually handled weekly (Smart campaigns on the Display Network). For search partners, Google says you may be able to request an opt out through support. A Search campaign lets you switch both off yourself.
Can I set an ad schedule on a Smart campaign?
Yes. You can run ads any time, during business hours or on custom hours. The business hours option needs a linked Business Profile, and if your profile has opening hours the schedule syncs to them (set an ad schedule for your Smart campaign).
Will I spend more on a Search campaign?
Not automatically, because you still set the budget. A Smart campaign won’t charge more than its maximum monthly budget, and a Search campaign runs on a daily budget that can go over on single days, as we explain in why Google Ads spends more than your daily budget. What changes is where the money goes: with a Search campaign you decide which searches and which hours get it.
Sources: 1. Compare Smart campaigns with other Google Ads campaign types (Google Ads Help). 2. How Smart campaigns work (Google Ads Help). 3. About Smart campaigns benefits and features (Google Ads Help). 4. About keyword themes in Smart campaigns (Google Ads Help). 5. About the search terms report in Smart campaigns (Google Ads Help). 6. About negative keyword themes in Smart campaigns (Google Ads Help). 7. Clicks and costs in Smart campaigns (Google Ads Help). 8. About goals in Smart campaigns (Google Ads Help). 9. Understanding reported calls (Google Ads Help). 10. Location settings in Smart campaigns (Google Ads Help). 11. About Smart campaigns on the Google Display Network (Google Ads Help). 12. Set an ad schedule for your Smart campaign (Google Ads Help). 13. Change your campaign type (Google Ads Help). 14. About keyword matching options (Google Ads Help). 15. About negative keywords (Google Ads Help). 16. About phone call conversion tracking (Google Ads Help). 17. Choose the right campaign type (Google Ads Help). 18. Pause or resume a Smart campaign (Google Ads Help).
